Intrinsic Desert Thesis Kant

Intrinsic Desert Thesis Kant-2
It is inegalitarian in that meritocracy is inherently hierarchical, holding that some people are better than others.

Life is an obstacle race with no special provision for the law but if one competitor trips up another, the state takes cognizance of this fact; thus compensation is given only when there is negligence on one side but not on the other.

Barry seems to be criticizing the notion of distributing according to desert from a socialist or communitarian perspective, viewing desert as an atomistic holdover from a Capitalist perspective.

So, the argument proceeds, we don't deserve what our talents produce.

Moral and intellectual excellence and superior ability to perform important tasks are from a moral point of view arbitrary and must not be used as bases for differential distribution of primary goods, including economic goods, social status, or respect.

Louis Pojman[*] Justice is a constant and perpetual will to give every man his due.

The principles of law are these: to live virtuously, not to harm others, to give his due to everyone.

Nagel argues that the morally right act is to move to the city for the sake of the handicapped child, thus promoting equality rather than overall flourishing.

Robert Goodin illustrates the principle of overriding desert for need.

Goodin asserts that even if everyone has clear knowledge of the facts, it would be morally outrageous to give preferential treatment to the innocent victim.

The right to equal treatment and to having one’s needs met trumps desert.


Comments Intrinsic Desert Thesis Kant

  • The Intrinsic Wrong of Privatization_Chicago UCB - Berkeley.

    The intrinsic wrong of privatization, I will suggest, rather consists in the creation of an. reconstruction of Kant's Doctrine of Right, I will argue that current forms of privatization. This essay is structured as follows. changing the principle of distribution from one of need, desert or love to one of market exchange, is.…

  • Kant's theory of the highest good - General Guide To Personal.

    E highest good is the culmination of Kant's ethical theory. in the highest good because it is intrinsically good when it is deserved, and if it were left out then. the second thesis, holding that maximality is not absolutely impossible but only. of justice and desert do not end up playing any foundational role but instead.…

  • Desert as a principle of distributive justice - CiteSeerX

    This followed an era – approximately, the one that saw the rise of utilitarianism, Kantian. 1 The natural-desert thesis desert and merit are something 'natural', prior to any. ously crucial to the revival of desert as a principle of justice as per thesis 2, since '. 'intrinsic. not merely instrumental value' Kagan, 2007 93.…

  • Kant on Wrongdoing, Desert, and Punishment - jstor

    Deserve it the intrinsic desert thesis. Fourth, I suggest that, despite appearances, this thesis is not implied by Kant's official theory of punishment either. Despite.…

  • Kant on environmental protection - MacSphere - McMaster.

    This thesis aims to develop a principled rationale for coercible environmental. notions of “harm”, “welfare”, the “public good” or the “intrinsic value of nature”. poison out onto some vast, waste, vacant, desert lands, lands belonging to no.…

  • Kantian ethics - Wikipedia

    Kantian ethics refers to a deontological ethical theory ascribed to the German philosopher Immanuel Kant. The theory, developed as a result of Enlightenment rationalism, is based on the view that the only intrinsically good thing is a good will; an action can only be.…

  • Punishment - TU Law Digital Commons

    A Principled Determination of the Degree of Desert. Kant's Maxim Does Not, and Should Not, Apply to. Retributivism's Use of. David Dolinko, Retributivism, Consequentialism, and the Intrinsic. Goodness of. justification issue by definition.40 For example, the retributivist thesis that an offender must.…

  • Pojman, Louis --- "Justice as Desert" 2001. - AustLII

    Many egalitarians view equality as an intrinsic good, good for its own sake as well. Moral desert corresponds to the Kantian good will, the intention to do one's. My thesis, which may be called “Justice as Merit” though “Justice as Desert”.…

  • Kant Morality - Philosophy Pages

    But a good will is intrinsically good; its value is wholly self-contained and utterly. According to Kant, then, the ultimate principle of morality must be a moral law.…

  • Immanuel Kant Theory of Justice - UK Essays

    Jul 20, 2017. The philosopher Immanuel Kant believed that his retributive theories of justice. 2214 words 9 pages Essay in Philosophy. the everyday thinking about punishment, the idea of desert figures prominently. in theory, cannot be achieved due to the complexity and intrinsic selfishness of human beings.…

The Latest from ©